🐶 Top 3 Dog Cake Flavors – Pup-Approved by Pupshoppe!

If there's one thing we know for sure, it's that dogs definitely have favorite flavors. At Pupshoppe, every cake is taste-tested and paw-approved by Albert, our head pup-in-charge 🐾 — and over time, a few flavors have emerged as the clear winners among our furry customers.

Whether you're celebrating a birthday or just feel like spoiling your good boy or girl, here are our top three most-loved cake flavors — and why dogs (and their humans) love them so much.

🥇 1. Pork Liver – The All-Time Bestseller

This is the flavor that started it all. Pork liver is our top-selling cake flavor, and it’s not just because of the smell (which dogs go crazy for).

Why Pork and Not Chicken?

Surprisingly, chicken is one of the most common allergens in dogs. We’ve had countless fur parents message us asking, “Is it chicken liver?” — and when they find out it's pork, they breathe a sigh of relief. Many go on to share stories about past allergy flare-ups from chicken-based treats.

That’s why we chose pork liver — it’s nutrient-rich, gentler on sensitive tummies, and a safer option for many dogs.

🐾 Albert’s verdict: “10/10 would lick the bowl again.”

🥕 2. Carrot – A Classic with Crunch and Benefits

Simple but beloved, our carrot cake is packed with natural sweetness and essential nutrients. Carrots are loaded with beta-carotene, fiber, and vitamins that support everything from vision to digestion.

It’s a great all-around option that feels indulgent but is sneakily healthy, too.

🐾 Bonus: We frost all our cakes with real mashed potatoes — never boxed mixes, and never any dairy like milk or cream, which are also common allergens for dogs. Just fresh, wholesome ingredients that pups can safely enjoy.

🍌 3. Mixed Berries + Banana – Our Egg-Free Special

We created this cake for the allergy-prone doggos who can’t tolerate eggs — but honestly, everyone loves it.

The base is made with ripe bananas (moist and sweet!) plus blueberries and cranberries for a burst of flavor and natural antioxidants. It’s soft, easy on the tummy, and free from both eggs and dairy.

If you’ve got a dog with a sensitive stomach or dietary restrictions, this is the one to try.

🐾 Fur-parent favorite: “Finally, a cake my egg-allergic baby can safely enjoy!”

Note: This cake is available by special order only. Please pre-order the Mixed Berry and Banana cake for dogs, as it’s not part of our regular menu at the moment.

🎂 Final Lick of Advice

Choosing the right cake flavor isn’t just about taste — it’s about knowing what’s safe, nourishing, and dog-approved. At Pupshoppe, we’re proud to bake with fresh, thoughtful ingredients that put your pup’s health first.

No dairy. No boxed mixes. Just love and real food, in every single bite.

✨ Ready to pick your dog’s dream cake?
Browse our full menu here, or message us on Instagram — we’re always happy to help match your pup with the perfect flavor.